Plan Review: LUME Creative Engine Maturation
- **Findings**: 15 (2 Critical / 4 High / 6 Medium / 3 Low) - **Cross-cutting patterns**: 3 (advisory protocol treated as atomic, missing dep declaration vs assumed-present, packet format arithmetic slippage) - **Plan health**: GO-with-fixes
Full Public Reader
# Plan Review: LUME Creative Engine Maturation
> Stage 5 of `/chain:genesis` — 6-pass meta-review of the plan, not shipped code.
> Reviewed: `divergent-rail.md` (Stage 4), `creative-forge-output.md` (Stage 3),
> `stage3-expand-master-plan.md` (Stage 2), `stage0-research.md` (Stage 1).
> Verified claims against repo state via Bash tooling as of 2026-05-02.
---
Summary
- Findings: 15 (2 Critical / 4 High / 6 Medium / 3 Low)
- Cross-cutting patterns: 3 (advisory protocol treated as atomic, missing dep declaration vs assumed-present, packet format arithmetic slippage)
- Plan health: GO-with-fixes
---
Findings by severity
Critical
| ID | Description | Location | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| C-01 | FirstDate PAT is live in the remote URL right now. `git -C Desktop/FirstDate remote -v` confirms `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` is in the fetch and push remote. The plan treats PAT rotation as Phase 0 Track A with a 20-min estimate and an explicit "rotated OR sentinel" escape hatch. The escape hatch means Mohamed can paste pane prompts while the token remains live. Any pane prompt that is logged, synced, or echoed to disk will carry context that references this credential path. The token itself has been in the remote URL since at least `d823a3a` (verified via `git remote -v`). | `stage0-research.md:A.11`, `divergent-rail.md:Phase 0 Track A` | Rotate the PAT before Phase 0 completes. Remove the escape hatch. The sentinel `WAVE8_PUSH_BLOCKED_PAT_ROTATION` is the right safety signal, but the plan must require rotation, not just documentation of the blocker. Rotate now: `git -C Desktop/FirstDate remote set-url origin https://github.com/Diomandeee/FirstDate.git` then revoke the old token via GitHub Settings → Tokens. |
| C-02 | Phase 0 coordination state is entirely absent — zero of 5 prerequisites exist. Verified: `[home-path]` = MISSING, `[home-path]` = MISSING, `.WAVE8_NOT_PUSHED` sentinel = MISSING, `[home-path]` = MISSING, `pane-prompt-P{1..5}.md` = MISSING. The rail plan's Phase 0 Gate reads "5 Codex pane prompts in evo-cube-output/, K11 health-check green, Mac4 reachable via Tailscale, FirstDate PAT rotation status confirmed, `[home-path]` directory created." None of these conditions are met. Mohamed cannot paste pane prompts because the prompts do not exist yet. The plan defines what Phase 0 must produce but no pane or task in Phase 0 generates the prompts themselves — there is a circular dependency: pane prompts are Phase 0 outputs, but Phase 0 requires pane prompts to already be open. | `divergent-rail.md:Phase 0 deliverables`, verified via Bash | The prompts must be written in this session (Stage 5) or in a dedicated pre-Phase-0 step, before any pane is opened. Stage 5 (this review) should close by writing `pane-prompt-P1.md` through `pane-prompt-P5.md` into `evo-cube-output/lume-creative-engine-2026-05-02/`. Add a "Stage 6: Prompt Bootstrap" step to the chain. |
---
High
| ID | Description | Location | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| H-01 | `ManagedAtomic<Int32>` is not available in MotionMixApp's dependency graph. The forge's LumfPublisher.swift V2 specification uses `ManagedAtomic` from `swift-atomics` for the SPSC ring buffer's head/tail pointers. The MotionMixApp Podfile has exactly one dependency: `GoogleWebRTC 1.1.32000`. There is no `swift-atomics` SPM dependency, no `Package.swift`, and `grep -c "Atomics"` on the xcodeproj returns 0. `ManagedAtomic` does not exist in scope. P1 will either hit a compile error on Day 1 or silently downgrade to a non-atomic integer, which introduces a data race on the audio render thread — exactly the failure mode the V2 ring-buffer design was meant to prevent. | `creative-forge-output.md:LumfPublisher implementation`, `MotionMixApp/Podfile` | P1's first subtask must be: add `swift-atomics` as an SPM dependency to the project (Xcode → File → Add Packages → `https://github.com/apple/swift-atomics`). Alternatively, replace `ManagedAtomic<Int32>` with a pair of `_Atomic(int32_t)` bridged via a thin C shim (already-available because Echelon's Rust FFI has a C bridge), or use OSAtomicAdd32 which is available on Apple platforms without additional deps. Either path must be explicit in P1's brief. |
| H-02 | `SANPipeline` type does not exist in MotionMixApp. `SANPipelineBridge.swift` (P4, forge Q1 §7.3) calls `sanPipeline?.latestPattern` and types `sanPipeline: SANPipeline?`. No `SANPipeline.swift` exists in `MotionMixApp/Services/`. No `class SANPipeline` or `struct SANPipeline` was found via grep. The SAN output exists embedded in `SANTrajectoryLogger.swift` as a C FFI struct (`output.pattern_intensity`, `output.pattern_variation`, `output.calibration_confidence`). There is no Swift-layer type that holds a `latestPattern: String` field with a `confidence: Double`. P4 is building against a phantom type. | `stage3-expand-master-plan.md:§7.3`, `SANTrajectoryLogger.swift:387` | P4's first deliverable must be a concrete interface spec: identify what existing type exposes SAN output (likely via `EchelonBridge` or `AutoDirector`), define a `SANOutput` (or extend `MotionMixState`) to surface `latestPattern: String?` and `patternConfidence: Double`. This must happen before `SANPipelineBridge.swift` is written, not concurrent with it. |
| H-03 | `pyorbbecsdk2` macOS arm64 wheel does not exist on PyPI. `pip3 download pyorbbecsdk2 --platform macosx_14_0_arm64` returns `ERROR: No matching distribution found`. The plan (P5, Stage 3 §5 Wave D item D3) says "verify pyorbbecsdk2 macOS arm64 wheel availability." It is not available. The fallback "document source-build steps in UNIVERSAL-SLED.md" is mentioned but no source-build procedure exists in any plan document. If Mac4 launchd `com.lume.depth.plist` requires `pyorbbecsdk2`, Mac4's depth service will not start without a source build. This blocks the 10-point Mac4 runbook points 3 and 4 (LUMD ≥28 Hz). | `stage3-expand-master-plan.md:P5 fourth task`, `divergent-rail.md:Phase 2 C` | The plan must escalate this from "verify + fallback doc" to "source-build path is the primary path on macOS arm64." P5 must include the source-build procedure at day 1 (not day 4) so that the build can run unattended during the photoshoot days. Minimum: `git clone https://github.com/orbbec/pyorbbecsdk && mkdir build && cmake .. -DPYTHON_EXECUTABLE=$(which python3) && make -j4 && pip install .` — document this in UNIVERSAL-SLED.md on Day 1, not Day 4. |
| H-04 | `OSCService.swift` is an OSC SENDER, not a receiver. The plan (P4) instructs Codex to "extend OSCService.swift to bind :9050 listener." Verified: `OSCService.swift` has no `NWListener`, no `bind`, no `9050` reference — it is a pure sender that sends to `targetAddress` via a 60Hz `DispatchSourceTimer`. P4's task assumes an extension pattern ("extend or revise, verify what's already there"), but the existing service architecture is directionally opposite (emit vs receive). Writing a listener inside a class designed as a sender will produce either a confusing bidirectional service or a clean rewrite. The plan's "additive only" constraint conflicts with the architectural mismatch. | `stage3-expand-master-plan.md:§7.2`, `MotionMixApp/Services/OSCService.swift:24-114` | Rename the existing class to `OSCEmitterService` or create `OSCReceiverService.swift` as a separate file. Do not extend a sender class into a receiver. P4's pane brief must state: "OSCService.swift sends; create OSCReceiverService.swift with NWListener binding :9050 consuming 7 channels." This preserves the additive-only constraint correctly. |
---
Medium
| ID | Description | Location | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| M-01 | LUMF byte-layout arithmetic mismatch between forge spec and golden test. The forge's LumfPublisher pull() comment says "4 + 12 + 16 + 32 = 64. Remaining 20 bytes: reserved/padding." But the golden test shows the actual layout as: magic(4) + frame(4) + sample_rate(4) + fft_size(4) + band_count(2) + flags(2) + rms(4) + centroid(4) + onset(4) + dt(4) = 36 bytes header, then 4 bands×4 + 8 mfcc×4 = 48 bytes body = 84 total. The forge's compact layout (rms+centroid+onset = 12 bytes, no frame/sr/fft_size/band_count/flags/dt fields) is a different, simpler format that does NOT match the golden-bytes test. If P1 implements the forge's compact layout, the golden test will fail at byte 4 (frame index mismatch). | `creative-forge-output.md:pull() comment`, `test_wire_format_golden.py:39-72` | P1's brief must direct the implementer to the golden test as ground truth, not the forge's pseudocode. The golden test's `expected_header` at 36 bytes is authoritative. Forge comment is aspirational/simplified. |
| M-02 | Claim-file protocol is advisory, not atomic — race condition window exists. The coordination protocol (Rule 2) says "before any Edit or Write, run `cat [home-path] | grep -F <target-path>`". This is a read-then-write with no exclusive lock. If two panes check simultaneously, both see no conflict and both proceed to write. The Wave 8 lesson the rail cites ("later writer won, earlier wasted edits") is exactly this race. The claim file scheme reduces collision probability but does not eliminate it. Under 5 simultaneous panes the window is real, especially for high-contention files like `AudioEngine.swift` (touched by P1, P2, and indirectly P4). | `divergent-rail.md:Coordination protocol Rules 1-3` |
| M-03 | `NSLock` in AudioEngine's consumer-array hot path violates audio-thread contract. The forge specifies `consumerLock = NSLock()` in `registerMixerConsumer` and the tap callback calls all consumers. If the tap callback acquires the lock to read the consumer array, it can block if `registerMixerConsumer` is being called concurrently. `NSLock.lock()` is not async-signal-safe; calling it from an audio render thread (priority-inverted under load) is a known audio dropout vector. The forge comment "contention only on register/deregister" is correct that contention is rare, but rare blocking on a real-time thread = audible dropout when it happens. | `creative-forge-output.md:AudioEngine.swift refactor, consumerLock` | Use a copy-on-write array instead of a lock: consumers are registered once at app startup, so copy the array atomically at registration time (`var consumersCopy = [MixerBufferConsumer](consumers); mixerConsumers = consumersCopy`). The audio thread reads an immutable value-type snapshot. No lock, no priority inversion. If dynamic registration is genuinely needed, use `os_unfair_lock` (adaptive spin, lower overhead than `NSLock` on the Apple RT scheduler). |
| M-04 | Pre-commit hook does not survive `git clone`. `PRE-COMMIT-DONT-TOUCH.sh` is planned as a repo file, but git hooks are not committed (`.git/hooks/` is gitignored by default). Verified: `lume-commerce/.git/hooks/pre-commit` does not exist. The hook requires manual installation via `install-mac4.sh` or equivalent. When Mac4 clones `lume-commerce` fresh, it will have no hook. The plan's "install in 3 repos" step (Phase 2 Track A, P3 task) mitigates this on the machines it runs on, but any fresh clone (disaster recovery, new machine, Codex sandbox) will operate without protection. | `divergent-rail.md:Phase 2 Track A`, `stage3-expand-master-plan.md:P3 fifth task` | Add a `git config core.hooksPath` entry pointing to a committed `software/demo/hooks/` directory. This commits the hook scripts and makes them active post-clone without a manual install step. Alternatively, ship a `Makefile` target `make install-hooks` that `install-mac4.sh` calls, and document in UNIVERSAL-SLED.md that new clones must run `make install-hooks`. |
| M-05 | Director schema sub-rail (forge Q2) has no consumer-side contract for the Rust impl. `Models+Director.swift` (P3, Phase 2) ships the Codable schema. The matching Rust impl (`multicam-server/src/director_bus.rs`) is deferred to Wave 9. But neither the rail plan nor the forge defines what the Rust-side wire format will be (JSON over WebSocket? MessagePack? Protobufs?). `MotionMixDirector/Sources/MotionMixDirector/Models.swift` already has its own model types that were NOT audited by Stage 0 as part of the director survey. Without a wire-format contract now, the Codable schema ships into a vacuum and the Wave 9 Rust impl will derive its own format — same drift problem the plan tries to prevent. | `creative-forge-output.md:Q2 Phase 5`, `divergent-rail.md:Phase 2 Track A (P3)` | The `director-protocol.md` doc (P3 Day 3) must include: (1) transport choice (recommend JSON-over-WebSocket mirroring MotionMixDirector's existing MJPEG/HTTP pattern), (2) a stub `director_bus.rs` struct derived from the Swift Codable types (even if stubbed as `todo!()`), and (3) a version field in `DirectorState` so Rust and Swift can handshake schema version at connect time. |
| M-06 | SANPipelineBridge accesses `audioEngine.bpm` without injection. `SANPipelineBridge.swift` (forge §7.3) computes `barSec = 4.0 * (60.0 / audioEngine.bpm)` but `audioEngine` is not a parameter, not injected, and not declared as a stored property on the struct. It appears to be a globals-style reference. On a `@MainActor` class this would require main-actor isolation; the `tick()` method (called from "AudioEngine 100ms ticker") may be off-main-actor. Implicit global access to `AudioEngine` is a data race if `tick()` is not @MainActor. | `creative-forge-output.md:§7.3 SANPipelineBridge.tick()` | Inject `audioEngine: AudioEngine` (weak ref) as a constructor parameter. `tick()` must be `@MainActor` or the `bpm` access must be wrapped in `await MainActor.run { ... }`. The forge shows `private weak var sanPipeline: SANPipeline?` and `private weak var strudel: StrudelWebEngine?` — add `private weak var audioEngine: AudioEngine?` to the same pattern. |
---
Low
| ID | Description | Location | Fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| L-01 | `health-check.ps1` line 36 short-circuit bug. Stage 0 flagged: `if (Test-Path $errF -and ((Get-Item $errF).Length -gt 0))` — PowerShell evaluates `-and` without guaranteed short-circuit before `Get-Item`; if the file does not exist, `Get-Item` throws rather than returning false. The bug is cosmetic today (services are running) but will surface as a diagnostic failure on the next K11 cold-boot where a service hasn't written its err.log yet. | `stage0-research.md:B.2`, `health-check.ps1:36` | Change to: `if ((Test-Path $errF) -and ((Get-Item $errF).Length -gt 0))`. The redundant parens force left-evaluation. Alternatively: `try { if (Test-Path $errF) { ... } } catch { }`. |
| L-02 | Strudel target IP is hardcoded (`[ip]:9600`) in StrudelWebEngine.swift. Stage 0 noted this (§C.1). The plan adds `setSANPattern` via an extension but doesn't fix the hardcoded Tailscale IP. If Mac5's IP changes (Tailscale re-assigns), Strudel goes dark silently with no error surfaced to the operator. | `stage0-research.md:C.1`, `creative-forge-output.md:S3 OSC path` | Override key `motionmix_strudelURL` already exists (line 26). P4's pane brief should include one additive step: ensure `StrudelWebEngine.init()` reads from `UserDefaults.standard.string(forKey: "motionmix_strudelURL")` with no hardcoded fallback IP (or at least logs a warning when using the hardcoded value). |
| L-03 | `sync-panes.py` is planned (Phase 2 Track A, P3) but its input format (`lume-pane-registry.json` schema) is only partially specified. The plan says the registry has "5 rows, status=PENDING" but doesn't define required keys beyond `id`, `focus`, `working_dir`, `current_task`, `last-commit-sha`, `status`. If P3 writes the registry and P5 writes to it independently with a different key set, `sync-panes.py` will produce incomplete state reports with no validation error. | `stage3-expand-master-plan.md:§Pane registry`, `divergent-rail.md:Phase 0 Track C` | Add a JSON schema (10 lines) to the registry initialization. `sync-panes.py` must validate each row against it on load and write a `SCHEMA_ERROR` row rather than crashing silently. |
---
Cross-cutting patterns
| Pattern | Affected passes | IDs | Root cause |
|---|---|---|---|
| Advisory-as-atomic: The plan defines coordination and safety mechanisms (claim files, pre-commit hook, WAVE8_NOT_PUSHED sentinel) as if they were enforced invariants, but all three are advisory: claim files have a race window, the hook isn't installed, the sentinel file doesn't exist yet. When a plan's safety mechanisms are described in the language of hard guarantees but implemented as soft conventions, the gap only surfaces under adversarial conditions (concurrent writes, fresh clone, compacted session). | Pass 2, Pass 5 | C-02, M-02, M-04 | The plan was written before the mechanisms were instantiated. The chain produced the specification of safety but not the execution of setup. |
| Missing-dep-declared-as-present: Three components are specified against types/packages that don't exist in the current codebase (`ManagedAtomic`, `SANPipeline`, OSC listener in `OSCService`). The forge synthesized correct design from first principles but didn't cross-check against the actual import graph and service directory. | Pass 3, Pass 4 | H-01, H-02, H-04 | Stage 3 (creative:forge) synthesized from Stage 0 research, but Stage 0 catalogued service files not type declarations. The gap: file presence was verified, type availability was not. |
| Packet-format-arithmetic drift: The forge's LumfPublisher pseudocode carries a compact "4+12+16+32=64" byte calculation that differs from the golden test's actual 36-byte header. This is a silent spec fork — neither version is wrong in isolation, but they describe different wire formats. Any pane that implements from the forge pseudocode will collide with the golden test. | Pass 1, Pass 3 | M-01 | The forge evolved the design independently of the golden test. Stage 4 (rail plan) cites both as authoritative but doesn't resolve the conflict. |
---
Priority matrix
| Rank | ID | Severity | Blast radius | Effort | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | C-01 | Critical | Security: live PAT, any pane context leak | 10 min | P0 |
| 2 | C-02 | Critical | No pane can start without prompts + coordination state | 2h | P0 |
| 3 | H-01 | High | P1 compile failure Day 1, blocks P2+P4 via consumer-array | 1h | P1 |
| 4 | H-04 | High | P4 architecture wrong direction, wastes Day 2 | 30 min brief fix | P1 |
| 5 | M-01 | Medium | P1 golden-byte test fails on Day 1 if forge pseudocode followed | 15 min brief fix | P1 |
| 6 | H-02 | High | P4 builds against phantom type, Day 4 work is invalid | 1h interface spec | P1 |
| 7 | H-03 | High | Mac4 depth service dead on arrival; blocks 10-point runbook | 30 min doc, 2h build | P2 |
| 8 | M-03 | Medium | Audio dropout risk (rare but audible); real-time thread safety | 30 min forge fix | P2 |
| 9 | M-02 | Medium | Race window remains, reduces value of coordination protocol | 1h shell-lock | P2 |
| 10 | M-04 | Medium | Hook lost on fresh clone; safety net has a hole | 30 min Makefile | P2 |
| 11 | M-05 | Medium | Director schema ships without transport contract | 2h stub Rust | P2 |
| 12 | M-06 | Medium | Data race risk in SANPipelineBridge.tick() | 15 min injection fix | P2 |
| 13 | L-01 | Low | health-check.ps1 crashes on cold boot | 5 min | P3 |
| 14 | L-02 | Low | Strudel goes dark silently on Tailscale IP change | 15 min | P3 |
| 15 | L-03 | Low | sync-panes.py produces partial state with no validation | 30 min schema | P3 |
---
Remediation roadmap (waves)
Wave 1 — Must-fix BEFORE Mohamed pastes pane prompts
C-01 — PAT rotation: Mohamed runs `git -C Desktop/FirstDate remote set-url origin https://github.com/Diomandeee/FirstDate.git`, then revokes `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` via GitHub → Settings → Personal access tokens. Confirm with `git -C Desktop/FirstDate remote -v` showing no token in URL. This takes 10 minutes and is unblockable.
C-02 — Pane prompts + Phase 0 state: Stage 5 (this session) or a "Stage 6: Prompt Bootstrap" step must produce:
- `pane-prompt-P1.md` through `pane-prompt-P5.md` in `evo-cube-output/lume-creative-engine-2026-05-02/`
- `mkdir -p [home-path] [home-path]`
- Touch `Desktop/lume-commerce/.WAVE8_NOT_PUSHED`
- Write `[home-path]` skeleton
H-01 (brief fix): Add to P1's pane prompt: "swift-atomics is NOT in the Podfile. Either add it via SPM before writing LumfPublisher.swift, or replace ManagedAtomic with os_unfair_lock + plain Int32 (acceptable on Apple platforms without external deps)."
H-04 (brief fix): Add to P4's pane prompt: "OSCService.swift is a UDP SENDER (no bind, no listener). Create a new file `OSCReceiverService.swift` with NWListener binding :9050. Do NOT extend OSCService.swift — the architecture is directionally opposite."
M-01 (brief fix): Add to P1's pane prompt: "The wire format ground truth is `tests/test_wire_format_golden.py`. The forge pseudocode shows a compact layout — IGNORE the forge's byte arithmetic. The golden test shows a 36-byte header (magic+frame+sr+fft_size+band_count+flags+rms+centroid+onset+dt) + 48-byte body (4 bands + 8 MFCC) = 84 bytes. Implement against the golden test, not the forge sketch."
---
Wave 2 — Must-fix before Day 1 commit
H-02: P4's pane prompt must include: "There is no `SANPipeline` class in MotionMixApp. SAN output lives in `SANTrajectoryLogger.swift` as a C FFI struct. Before writing `SANPipelineBridge.swift`, identify where the SAN output is exposed in the Swift layer (check `AutoDirector.swift`, `MotionMixState.swift`). Define or locate a `sanLatestPattern: String?` and `sanPatternConfidence: Double` accessor. This is a prerequisite to the bridge."
H-03: P5's pane prompt must escalate pyorbbecsdk2 to Day 1: "pip3 download returns ERROR on macOS arm64 — no wheel exists. Source-build is the path. On Day 1, clone `https://github.com/orbbec/pyorbbecsdk`, install cmake + OpenCV (`brew install cmake opencv`), build and install. Document the exact commands in UNIVERSAL-SLED.md Day 1. Do not defer to Day 4."
M-03: Add to P1's pane prompt: "Do NOT use NSLock in the audio tap callback path. The consumer array must be read lock-free. Use a value-type copy: on registration, atomically swap the array. The tap callback reads a stack-local copy (no lock). See Swift's built-in CoW semantics for [MixerBufferConsumer]."
M-04: P3's pane prompt must include: "After writing PRE-COMMIT-DONT-TOUCH.sh, add `git config core.hooksPath software/demo/hooks/` to `install-mac4.sh` so any fresh clone activates the hook without a manual step."
M-06: Add to P4's pane prompt: "SANPipelineBridge.tick() reads `audioEngine.bpm`. Inject `audioEngine: AudioEngine` as a weak constructor param. Annotate `tick()` as `@MainActor` since it calls `strudel?.setSANPattern` which is also @MainActor."
---
Wave 3 — Must-fix before Day 5 reel post
M-02: Coordination hardening — add `flock` or `set -o noclobber` around claim-file writes in pane briefing docs. Or declare AudioEngine.swift single-owner-at-a-time in the registry, removing the multi-pane race entirely for the highest-contention file.
M-05: P3 must include in `director-protocol.md`: a JSON-over-WebSocket transport decision, a `schema_version` field in `DirectorState`, and a stub `director_bus.rs` (even `todo!()`) so Wave 9 has a compile-checked starting point.
L-01, L-02, L-03: Low-effort polish — health-check.ps1 short-circuit fix (5 min), Strudel IP warning log (15 min), pane-registry JSON schema (30 min).
---
Plan verdict
GO-with-fixes
The plan is architecturally sound. The 5-pane structure, EW-governed phase gates, forge-selected V2+S3 audio architecture, and No-Absorbing-States discipline are all correct decisions. The rail is executable. However, two blocking conditions must clear before Mohamed pastes any pane prompt: (1) the FirstDate PAT must be rotated — it is live in the remote URL today and any session context could carry it forward; (2) the Phase 0 coordination state (pane prompts, claim directories, sentinel, registry) must be bootstrapped — it is entirely absent. Beyond those blockers, four High findings represent plan-level spec errors (wrong Swift dep, phantom SANPipeline type, wrong OSCService direction, missing pyorbbecsdk2 source-build path) that will generate Day-1 compile failures or Day-4 dead-end work if not corrected in the pane prompts before opening. With all Wave 1 fixes applied to the pane briefs and C-01 rotated, the plan can proceed. The 7-day reel deadline is achievable.
Promotion Decision
Attach run IDs, datasets, metrics, and reproduction commands.
Source Anchor
evo-cube-output/lume-creative-engine-2026-05-02/meta-review.md
Detected Structure
Method · Evaluation · References · Code Anchors · Architecture · is Stage Research